Headline News

‘Cinderella.. If the Shoe Fits,’ a rollicking good time on now at South Simcoe Theatre

November 19, 2026   ·   0 Comments

By Brian Lockhart

Be prepared to be part of the action in the South Simcoe Theatre’s production of Cinderella… If the Shoe Fits, now on stage at the Cookstown Theatre.

Written by Debbie Collins and David Nairn, who describe the production as “same story, different boots,” since it takes the old tale of Cinderella and adds some twists, zany characters, outlandish buffoonery, and a lot of good jokes and songs.

Directed by Nancy Chapple and produced by Mel Hinch, Cinderella… If the Shoe Fits is performed in the pantomime style of theatre.

Pantomime is a centuries-old theatre tradition that brings the audience into the show. It has larger-than-life characters, outrageous humour, good characters, bad characters, men in women’s roles, and women in men’s roles.

The audience is encouraged to boo some characters while cheering for others. The characters react with the audience, sometimes taunting them to do better with their efforts.

The dialogue and jokes are unique, as many lines have references to local towns and establishments, providing an even bigger laugh for audience members who live in the region.

You may have to be of a certain age to really get some of the jokes. If ‘Joe who?’ rings a bell, you’re definitely not a teenager.

As Celeste the Fairy, Hanh Nguyen introduces the characters and chapters with a lot of enthusiasm and her magic wand.

In the title role of Cinderella, Madison Olivier brings the character to life in a modern setting. Living on a farm, Cinderella is tormented by her evil stepmother and bullied by her two ugly stepsisters.

The two ugly stepsisters, played by Tom Mercer and Martin Buote, certainly live up to their description. The stepsisters are looking for husbands, but it is easy to see why they are having such difficulties finding a mate.

In the role of the wicked stepmother, Michelle Herman admits she has an evil side and encourages the audience to show disdain for her character.

In the role of Buttons, Avery Nickerson is Cinderella’s best friend and confidant. She offers advice to Cinderella on how to defeat her evil stepmother.

Benjamin Khoa Van Canedo steps into the role of William King — a man from an influential family. He just wants to be able to go into town and not be recognized for his wealth. He takes a real liking to Cinderella when he meets her.

In the role of The Old Cheese Peddler, Judy Erickson is a veteran director/producer with the South Simcoe Theatre and is back on stage for this production to bring the character to life.

Jason Bowers brings the character of Mr. King to the stage. A veteran actor of many productions, Bowers is thrilled to unleash his comic talent for this play.

There are several songs in the production, and as usual, The South Simcoe Theatre has put together a group of talented musicians who perform live and support the characters and songs being performed on stage.

The musicians include Tobin Lippold on bass guitar, Jay Rothenburg on drums, Debbie Silverthorne on trumpet, and Daryl Yaeger on trumpet.

The on-stage dancing is choreographed by Siena Ierullo-Gerrior.

Cinderella… If the Shoe Fits is on stage at The South Simcoe Theatre through Nov. 29, on Fridays and Saturdays, with a Sunday matinee.

For tickets, visit the website at: thesouthsimcoetheatre.com


Readers Comments (0)


You must be logged in to post a comment.